babewiththepower.bsky.social · @babewiththepower.bsky.social@bridge.neodb.net
Rated Louis Riel: A Comic-Strip Biography 6/10
Having heard my husband talk for years about how much he admires Louis Riel I figured I'd read something about the man. Having borrowed this copy from the local library in the middle of the COVID pandemic and via "contact-free hold and pick-up" I didn't realize until I had it that this wasn't a novel biography, but a black and white comic. My opinion before and after reading it is that it wasn't the best idea to read about this historical person in this format. Events and real people are highly condensed and in some places greatly exaggerated while in others highly accurate, just no real consistency in accuracy. Because I'm almost completely unfamiliar with the history involved I couldn't make a good judgement on which was which. The author, Brown, does deeply annotate the book with end notes, but at first I tried to go back and forth and it just became too tedious and discouraged me from wanting to pick up the book. Ultimately, I just went through the comic and didn't read any more of the end notes. I really only got a general idea of the events involving Riel and the conflict between the Métis people in northwest territories and the government of Canada.<br/><br/>As for the art style, it's similar to Little Orphan Annie which was Brown's goal and the dialogue is pretty straight-forward with little injected personal feelings and drama and quite a few panels without even dialogue, the narrative moving forward through character actions instead. One thing I'd never heard of Louis Riel is his stints in several mental institutions and having episodes that to me sound like schizophrenic episodes. Brown's mother had schizophrenia and I think that influenced how he portrayed Riel's reported behaviors of thinking himself a prophet and some sort of savior and various other types of outbursts and misbehaviors. A little more background research on Brown tells me that he started out as an anarchist when researching for this book, but inched towards the center after all his findings regarding property rights becoming an active member of the libertarian party of Canada. Go figure.<br/><br/>So, overall I wouldn't recommend this for anyone as ignorant of the subject matter as I was. I definitely need to pick up a more traditional novel biography and it would be REALLY interesting to read a take on Riel and the Métis history from Indigenous or Métis writers instead.
#book
Published · bridged from Atmosphere
ActivityPub object: https://bridge.neodb.net/users/babewiththepower.bsky.social/posts/3mtesbbxpqeby
AT Protocol record: at://did:plc:u2673mqre3hgx32l6yv3vne2/buzz.bookhive.book/3mtesbbxpqeby